MONTEREY INSTITUTE OF INTERNATIONAL STUDIES

CENTER FOR NONPROLIFERATION STUDIES

 

Critical Issues Forum 2006-2007

Space: Forum for Cooperation or Next Frontier for WMD Proliferation?

 

High School 125, Snezhinsk, Russian Federation

Student: Anna Melnikova

Teacher: Marina Chebysheva

 

Benchmark I

Objective 1 - Definitions

Our known planetary universe, space in the vicinity of Earth and the atmosphere adjacent to Earth

Some units of measure of distances in space

The average distance of the earth to the sun is used as a standard for measuring distances in the solar system and is called an astronomical unit (AU). One AU is about 150 million kilometers.

A light-year is the distance light travels in vacuum in one Julian year. A light-year is equal to 9,460,730,472,580.8 km and 63,241.077 AU.

Solar System

The solar system is a place we live in. What do we know about it? For a long time the mankind has been preserving and increasing its knowledge about it. For years astronomers have been preserving all the necessary information about the Universe adding more and more facts. Today this information is rather vast.

The solar system [1-2] consists of the Sun, the eight planets, three dwarf planets, more than 160 satellites of the planets (moons), a large number of small bodies (asteroids, meteoroids, comets) and interplanetary medium. The Sun is the star at the center of the Solar System, which accounts for more than 99% of the solar system’s mass. The Earth and other matter orbit the Sun. The inner solar system contains the Sun, Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars. Between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter lies the main asteroid belt. The planets of the outer solar system are Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. Beyond the orbit of Neptune lies the Kuiper belt - a second belt of small icy bodies. Pluto, considered a planet for 76 years, was reclassified as a dwarf planet in 2006. Two other dwarf planets are Ceres, the largest object in the asteroid belt, and Eris, which lies beyond the Kuiper belt.

The four innermost planets in the solar system (Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars) are called terrestrial planets because they have a compact, rocky surface like the Earth’s. The planets, Venus, Earth, and Mars have significant atmospheres while Mercury has almost none. Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune are known as the Jovian (Jupiter-like) planets, because they are all gigantic compared with Earth, and they have a gaseous nature like Jupiter’s. The Jovian planets are also referred to as the gas giants, although some or all of them might have small solid cores.

The eight planets (Sun, Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune) and Pluto with approximately correct relative sizes

(http://www2.jpl.nasa.gov/galileo/sepo/education/nav/ss2.gif)

 

The planets, most of the satellites of the planets and the asteroids revolve around the Sun in the same direction, in nearly circular orbits. When looking down from above the Sun’s north pole, the planets orbit in a counter-clockwise direction. The planets orbit the Sun in or near the same plane, called the ecliptic. Pluto is a special case in that its orbit is the most highly inclined (18 degrees) and the most highly elliptical of all the planets. Because of this, for part of its orbit, Pluto is closer to the Sun than is Neptune. The axis of rotation for most of the planets is nearly perpendicular to the ecliptic. The exceptions are Uranus and Pluto, which are tipped on their sides.

Solar System Live by John Walker (http://www.fourmilab.ch/solar/solar.html)

 

Comets are small, fragile, irregularly shaped bodies composed of a mixture of non-volatile grains and frozen gases. They have highly elliptical orbits that bring them very close to the Sun and swing them deeply into space, often beyond the orbit of Pluto. Each time a comet visits the Sun, it loses some of its volatiles. Eventually, it becomes just another rocky mass in the solar system. Many scientists believe that some asteroids are extinct comet nuclei, comets that have lost all of their volatiles.

Asteroids are rocky and metallic objects that orbit the Sun but are too small to be considered planets. They are known as minor planets. Asteroids range in size from Ceres, which has a diameter of about 1000 km, down to the size of pebbles. They have been found inside Earth’s orbit to beyond Saturn’s orbit. Most, however, are contained within a main belt that exists between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter. Asteroids that are on a collision course with Earth are called meteoroids. When a meteoroid strikes our atmosphere at high velocity, friction causes this chunk of space matter to incinerate in a streak of light known as a meteor. If the meteoroid does not burn up completely, what’s left strikes Earth’s surface and is called a meteorite.

Interplanetary medium

The space between the planets is far from empty. It contains: electromagnetic radiation (photons); plasma (electrons, protons and other ions) a.k.a. the solar wind; cosmic rays; microscopic dust particles; and magnetic fields (primarily the Sun’s). The temperature of the interplanetary medium is about 100,000 K. Its density is about 5 particles/cm3 near the Earth and decreases farther from the Sun. However, the density is highly variable; it can be as much as 100 particles/cm3. The highest energy particles in the interplanetary medium are called cosmic rays. Some are of solar origin; the most energetic, however, originate in some other unknown and very energetic processes outside our solar system. Except near some of the planets, interplanetary space is filled with the Sun’s magnetic field. Its interactions with the solar wind are very complicated. Within a few solar radii of the Sun the magnetic field determines the flow of the solar wind; much of the flow is trapped in magnetic loops. But some regions of the Sun’s magnetic field are open allowing the solar wind to escape. Farther out the plasma dominates and the magnetic field is entrained in the particle flow. Some planets (e.g. Earth, Jupiter) have their own magnetic fields. These create smaller magnetospheres that dominate the Sun’s influence within their boundaries. The Earth’s magnetosphere extended only to a few thousand km, but protects us from the otherwise very dangerous effects of the solar wind. For non-magnetic bodies, such as the Moon, the solar wind impacts the surface directly. The speed of the solar wind is about 400 kilometers per second in the vicinity of Earth’s orbit. The point at which the solar wind meets the interstellar medium, which is the “solar” wind from other stars, is called the heliopause. It is a boundary theorized to be roughly circular or teardrop-shaped, marking the edge of the Sun’s influence perhaps 100 AU from the Sun. The space within the boundary of the heliopause, containing the Sun and solar system, is referred to as the heliosphere.

Interplanetary space (image from [2])

The question where exactly the Solar system ends and the interstellar space starts, is ambiguous, as it is connected with the influence of two different phenomena – the solar wind and the solar gravitation. Even far beyond the boundary of the heliopause, the Sun is able to retain by its gravitation other objects − up to the Oort cloud – large clusters of comets surrounding the Solar system that stretch at the distance from 50,000 to 100,000 AU, almost a light year.

 

Milky Way

The Sun’s nearest known stellar neighbor is a red dwarf star called Proxima Centauri, at a distance of 4.3 light years away. The whole solar system, together with the local stars visible on a clear night, orbits the center of our home galaxy, a spiral disk of 200 billion stars we call the Milky Way [3]. Like all spiral galaxies, the Milky Way has three main components: a disk, a central bulge, and a large halo. In the picture below, the disk is seen edge on, the bulge is the spherical white blob in the center, and the halo is made of the Globular Clusters (seen as white dots) filling the rest of the picture.

The Milky Way Galaxy (http://www.astro.umd.edu/education/astro/mw/mw.html)

 

The Milky Way has two small galaxies orbiting it nearby, which are visible from the southern hemisphere. They are called the Large Magellanic Cloud and the Small Magellanic Cloud. The nearest large galaxy is the Andromeda Galaxy. It is a spiral galaxy like the Milky Way but is 4 times as massive and is 2 million light years away. Current measurements suggest the Andromeda Galaxy is approaching us at 100 to 140 kilometers per second, and that the Milky Way might collide with it in several (3-4) billion years, depending on the importance of unknown lateral components to the galaxies’ relative motion. Our galaxy, one of billions of galaxies known, is traveling through intergalactic space spreading outwards from the centre of the universe as the universe expands.

The Earth’s atmosphere

The earth’s atmosphere is a thin layer of gases wrapped around our planet. The present composition of the atmosphere is 79% nitrogen, 20% oxygen, 1% other “trace” gases (argon, carbon dioxide) and water vapor. This mixture of gases is commonly known as air.

Five distinct layers of atmosphere have been identified using temperature changes, chemical composition, movement and density [5]. Each of the layers are bounded by “pauses” where the maximum changes in this characteristics occur.

An average temperature profile through the lower layers of the atmosphere (from [4])

The troposphere begins at the Earth’s surface and extends up 7-18 km high. The temperature in the troposphere decreases with height from about 17°C to -51°C. Almost all weather occurs in this region. The height of the troposphere varies from the equator to the poles. The transition boundary between the troposphere and the layer above is called the tropopause. Both the tropopause and the troposphere are known as the lower atmosphere.

The stratosphere extends from the tropopause up to 50 km above the Earth’s surface. This layer holds 19 percent of the atmosphere’s gases and but very little water vapor.Temperature increases with height as radiation is increasingly absorbed by oxygen molecules which leads to the formation of Ozone. The temperature rises from an average -60°C at tropopause to a maximum of about -15°C at the stratopause due to this absorption of ultraviolet radiation. The increasing temperature also makes it a calm layer with movements of the gases slow. The regions of the stratosphere and the mesosphere, along with the stratopause and mesopause, are called the middle atmosphere by scientists. The transition boundary which separates the stratosphere from the mesosphere is called the stratopause.

The mesosphere extends from the stratopause to about 85 km above the earth. The gases, including the oxygen molecules, continue to become thinner and thinner with height. As such, the effect of the warming by ultraviolet radiation also becomes less and less leading to a decrease in temperature with height. On average, temperature decreases from about -15°C to as low as -120°C at the mesopause. However, the gases in the mesosphere are thick enough to slow down meteorites hurtling into the atmosphere, where they burn up.

The thermosphere extends from the mesopause to 690 km above the earth. This layer is known as the upper atmosphere. The thermosphere is very thin, but it is where aurora take place, and is also responsible for absorbing the most energetic photons from the Sun, and for reflecting radio waves, thereby making long-distance radio communication possible. The structure of the termosphere is strongly influenced by the charged particle wind from the Sun (solar wind), which is in turn governed by the level of Solar activity. The temperature increases with height and can reach as high as 2000°C near the top of this layer.

The exosphere is the most distant atmospheric region from Earth’s surface. In the exosphere, an upward travelling molecule can escape to space (if it is moving fast enough) or be pulled back to Earth by gravity (if it isn’t) with little probability of colliding with another molecule. The altitude of its lower boundary, known as the thermopause, ranges from about 250 to 500 km depending on solar activity. The upper boundary is relatively undefined. The exosphere is a transitional zone between Earth’s atmosphere and interplanetary space.

The upper atmosphere is also divided into regions based on the behavior and number of free electrons and other charged particles.

The ionosphere is defined by atmospheric effects on radiowave propagation as a result of the presence and variation in concentration of free electrons in the atmosphere. D-region is about 60 - 90 km in altitude but disappears at night. E-region is about 90 - 140 km in altitude. F-region is above 140 km in altitude. During the day it has two regions known as the F1-region from about 140 to 180 km altitude and the F2-region in which the concentration of electrons peaks in the altitude range of 250 to 500 km. The ionosphere above the peak electron concentration is usually referred to as the Topside Ionosphere.

Earth’s plasmasphere (image from [6])

 

The plasmasphere is essentially an extension of the ionosphere. It is a torus-shaped region with the hole aligned with Earth’s magnetic axis. It is made of plasma, the fourth state of matter, which composed mostly of hydrogen ions (protons) and electrons. Plasmasphere has a very sharp edge called the plasmapause. The outer edge of this “doughnut” over the equator is usually some 4 to 6 Earth radii from the center of the Earth (19,000-32,000 km). Inside of the plasmapause, geomagnetic field lines rotate with the Earth. The inner edge of the plasmasphere is taken as the altitude at which protons replace oxygen as the dominant species in the ionospheric plasma which usually occurs at about 1000 km altitude.

Earth’s magnetophere (image from [6])

 

Outside the plasmapause, magnetic field lines are unable to corotate because they are influenced strongly by electric fields of solar wind origin. The magnetosphere is a cavity (also not spherical) in which the Earth’s magnetic field is constrained by the solar wind and interplanetary magnetic field (IMF). The outer boundary of the magnetosphere is called the magnetopause. The magnetosphere is shaped like an elongated teardrop with the tail pointing away from the Sun. The magnetopause is typically located at about 10 Earth radii or about 56,000 km above the Earth’s surface on the day side and stretches into a long tail, the magnetotail, a few million km long (about 1000 Earth radii) on the night side of the Earth.

The magnetopause marks the outer limit of Earth’s gaseous envelope. Beyond the magnetopause are the magnetosheath and bow shock which are regions in the solar wind disturbed by the presence of Earth and its magnetic field.

Definition of space

We can define the term of “outer space” (or simply “space”) as the relatively empty regions of the universe outside the atmosphere of Earth. But there is no definite boundary between the atmosphere and space. It slowly becomes thinner and fades away into space. But even at 1000 kilometers, there is a trace of the Earth’s “hydrogen cloud” as its outer atmosphere (it is called the geocorona). The Karman line at 100 km is frequently used as the boundary between atmosphere and outer space. This definition is accepted by the Fédération Aéronautique Internationale (FAI), which is an international standard setting and record-keeping body for aeronautics and astronautics. Around this altitude the Earth’s atmosphere becomes too thin for aeronautic purposes. The China’s Science of Campaigns defines space as beginning at 120 km above the earth because “aeronautical maneuvering and jet propelling are of little effect” and because “vehicles can maintain an orbit around the Earth for a certain period of time” [7].

TV series “Cosmos”

An educational BBC TV series “Space” tells how wonderful, but how at the same time mortally dangerous is the Universe where we live. We can see how vast and endless the Universe is. It is a fascinating and colorful story about the greatest mysteries of the Universe: the birth of supernovas and the death of whole star systems, about blue giants and red dwarfs, about structure and the origin of our Solar system. The most advanced shooting techniques involving computer graphics and unique shots obtained with the help of space technology have been used in the series. The series consists of three parts.

Part 1. Life. Everything of which a human body and the surrounding environment consist of appeared long time ago out of space. Nearly half a century the humankind has been studying the neighboring planets, submerging into alien unexplored worlds, seeking an answer to the main questions:

How did the Earth appear? Hydrogen sustains combustion of stars. But hydrogen burns down, and the star dies, compressing and accumulating tremendous energy. A powerful explosion takes place – a supernova is born, scattering elements of life all over the Universe giving birth to new stars and planets.

How did life appear on our planet? The first Earth inhabitants were probably the simplest microorganisms that came to the Earth from space on comets. Favorable conditions on the Earth promoted rapid development of life.

Are we alone in the Universe? So far, there is no universal answer to this question. What should we expect from meeting with other sentient beings? There are many questions, but there are no exact answers so far.

Part 2. Survival. We are lucky to have survived, although life on the Earth was at the brink of extinction many times. Let us take a walk over planet Earth – it is a wonderful place, with life in most astonishing forms everywhere. We take all this for granted. In vain! Because one day everything can disappear forever. This is a story about the Universe, where we live, about dangers, which we encounter. We will witness a catastrophe that has nearly destroyed the planet, we will fly with comets and asteroids that threaten life on the Earth, we will meet invisible monsters of the Universe − black holes. We will learn about catastrophes that mean an end to all of us. Our planet is under a threat, and our task is to survive. There is still another question: how real is this threat?

Part 3. Density. The temperature of the Sun constantly rises and in some distant future it may burn away all signs of life from the face of the Earth. The humankind will have to leave it and search for a new home on other planets of the Solar system, and maybe in other galaxies. Now we can learn about research in new technologies that will help our descendants reach the stars.

Kinds of objects that have been put into space

During many years of human activity in space, more than 20,000 objects with a total mass exceeding 3,000 tons have been launched into different near-earth orbits and into deep space. Space control services have registered and are constantly monitoring over 10,000 objects on near-earth orbits. These are mainly rather large bodies with dimensions more than 10 cm. The 1974 UN Convention on Registration of Objects Launched into Outer Space provides for the national registration by launching states of space objects launched into outer space and for the maintenance of a central register of objects launched into outer space by the Secretary-General of the United Nations. Some registers available online in Internet [8-9].

Let us consider the main types of artificial objects, launched into space from the Earth (or other artificial objects).

Spacecraft is a device designed to operate beyond the surface of the Earth in outer space. Spacecraft are designed for a variety of missions which may include communications, earth observation, meteorology, navigation, planetary exploration, space tourism and space warfare. Spacecraft may either be unmanned or manned.

Artificial satellite is a spacecraft that orbits the Earth. Types of artificial satellites:

·      Anti-Satellite weapons (“Killer satellites”) - designed to destroy “enemy” satellites, other orbital weapons and targets.

·      Astronomical satellites - used for observation of distant planets, galaxies, and other outer space objects.

·      Biosatellites - designed to carry living organisms, generally for scientific experimentation.

·      Communications satellites – used for the purposes of telecommunications.

·      Miniaturized satellites are satellites of unusually low weights and small sizes. New classifications are used to categorize these satellites: minisatellite (500–200 kg), microsatellite (below 200 kg), nanosatellite (below 10 kg).

·      Navigation satellites are satellites which use radio time signals transmitted to enable mobile receivers on the ground to determine their exact location.

·      Reconnaissance (spy) satellites are Earth observation satellite or communications satellite deployed for military or intelligence applications.

·      Earth observation satellites are satellites intended for non-military uses such as environmental monitoring, meteorology, map making etc.

·      Weather satellites are satellites that primarily are used to monitor Earth’s weather and climate.

·      Space stations are man-made structures that are designed for human beings to live on in outer space. A space station is distinguished from other manned spacecraft by its lack of major propulsion or landing facilities — instead, other vehicles are used as transport to and from the station.

A space probe is an unmanned space mission in which a spacecraft leaves Earth’s orbit to explore other planets in the solar system and asteroids or comets (the first successful space probe was the Soviet Luna 1, which studied the Moon in 1959).

Unmanned rovers, landed on the Moon (Lunokhod) and Mars (Spirit, Opportunity) were primarily designed to explore the planet’s surface and return pictures.

A spaceplane (Space Shuttle, Buran) is a (manned or unmanned) rocket plane designed to pass the edge of space. It combines some of the features of an aircraft and some of a spacecraft. Typically, it takes the form of a spacecraft equipped with wings. Spaceplanes are reusable spacecrafts.

Space debris (space junk, space waste) are the objects in orbit around Earth created by humans that no longer serve any useful purpose. They consist of everything from entire spent rocket stages and defunct satellites to explosion fragments, paint flakes, dust and slag from solid rocket motors, coolant released by nuclear powered satellites.

Kinds of objects that might be put into space in the future

A space elevator is a structure designed to transport material from a planet’s surface into space. Many different types of space elevators have been suggested. They all share the goal of replacing rocket propulsion with the traversal of a fixed structure via a mechanism not unlike an elevator in order to move material into or beyond orbit. Space elevators have also sometimes been referred to as beanstalks, space bridges, space lifts, space ladders or orbital towers.

Solar power satellites are satellites in orbit around Earth that use power transmission to beam solar power to very large antennae on Earth where it can be used in place of conventional power sources.

A manned starship is a spacecraft designed for interstellar travel, specifically between star systems.

Scavengers are special spacecrafts designed for collection of space debris. They can either destroy it or collect it and transport it for recycling.

Space plants where hazardous substances or substances that require peculiar production conditions are produced. The weightless environment of space can be exploited for manufacturing of valuable products which cannot be produced on Earth, such as pharmaceuticals, semiconductors, hyper-pure materials and exotic alloys. Additionally, the pollutant-laden process of manufacturing products and chemicals could be moved off-world where the by-products so harmful to the delicate terrestrial ecosystem could be more safely dispersed into space.

Space weapons

What are “space weapons”? Probably, there is no precise answer to this question, because there are no precise definitions of the main terms, “space” and “weapon”. In the RAND report [10] noted: “By space weapons, we mean things intended to cause harm that are based in space or that have an essential element based in space. The degree of harm we include in defining space weapons may range from temporary disruption to permanent destruction or death. This definition does not include things that are based on the earth and transit space without achieving orbit, such as ballistic missiles… We also do not mean things in space … such as reconnaissance, navigation, weather or communications satellites … And while some of the space weapons we consider may also be useful against targets in space, our interest here is in war on earth rather than war in space.  …weapons against targets in space are old news, and all of them developed to date have been based on earth, not in space. We also do not mean information weapons that might use space-based communications for access to the database, decisionmaker, or computer that is their target”. This is a narrower definition which probably should be better called as “space-based weapons”.  Ref.  [7] offers such a definition of “space-based weapons”: “damage causing mechanisms (not associated elements such as sensors or command and control) actually based in space (not just transiting, like missiles or space planes)”.

Other definitions have a wider meaning and include “ground-based space weapons” as well, for example [11]: “We define space weapons and offensive space warfare initiatives as terrestrially based devices specifically designed and flight-tested to physically attack, impair, or destroy objects in space, or space-based devices designed and flight-tested to attack, impair, or destroy objects in space or on earth”.

Foreign Affairs Canada’s Space Security Index inclusively designates as space weapons “objects passing through space, via the projection of mass or energy” [12]. So ground-based high energy laser which bounces beams off a constellation of space-based mirrors (component of the US “Global Area Strike System”) is a space weapon.

There are also other approaches. Further we’ll follow last two definitions and shall not concern residual or latent space warfare capabilities, such as ballistic missiles. Also we excluded satellites and other spacecrafts that do not serve as weapon platforms (but they may be used for some military purposes, as for example spy satellites). So we bring to a focus things capable of direct attacks in or from space (or use essential component placed in space).

Space weapons are not all alike. They differ importantly in the physical principles they use, in the physical constraints that limit them, and in the targets they can attack [13]. Here are some kinds of up-to-date space weapons.

·      Directed-energy weapon. They direct destructive energy at very high speeds to their targets without transporting significant mass (ex. particle beam, high energy lasers, laser zappers, high-powered microwaves). In 1987, the Zenith Star prototype space combat satellite prototype, using the Alpha laser, was announced by President Bush. The launch vehicle would be the Barbarian. Zenith Star weighed 39.4 tonnes, and was to be launched at one time by a Barbarian clustered launch vehicle or in two elements aboard a Titan 4. In 1991 the Star Lite space laser experiment was made public. Star Lite would weigh half that of the previously planned Zenith Star with a launch mass of 16.3 tonnes, which could be launched by a single Titan 4. By 1996 the Star Lite space laser was replaced by the more refined and slightly heavier SLD (Space Laser Demo), weighing 17.4 tonnes). Two versions of the 20 meter long spacecraft were envisioned.  OKB Vympel (USSR) built the major Terra-3 laser testing centre at Sary Shagan in the 1970’s, which was eventually equipped with Astrofizika high energy red ruby and carbon dioxide lasers. The first applications would have to be limited to anti-satellite, and then primarily to blind optical sensors. As a ‘warning shot’ the Terra-3 complex was used to track the space shuttle Challenger with a low power laser on 10 October 1984.

·      Mass-to-target (kinetic-energy) weapons are “billets” accelerated to high speed and intended for destruction of enemy’s satellites, intercontinental ballistic missiles, and hitting targets on the surface of the Earth. A natural kinetic “weapon” is meteor. A “Long Rod Space Weapon” is a space-to-earth weapon (often nicknamed “Rods from God”) that has been under consideration since the 1980s. Long tungsten or uranium rods would be orbited, and then “de-orbited” by canceling their orbital velocity, so that they would fall essentially vertically through the atmosphere, striking their target with enormous energy. The system would consist of tandem satellites, one serving as a communications platform, the other carrying a number of tungsten rods, each up to 20 feet in length and 1 foot in diameter. These rods, which could be dropped on a target with as little as 15 minutes notice, would enter the Earth’s atmosphere about as fast as a meteor. Upon impact, the rod would be capable of producing all the effects of an earth-penetrating nuclear weapon, without any of the radioactive fallout.

·      Anti-satellite (ASAT) weapons include ground-based high-energy weapons, ground- or air-launched interceptor missiles, or ‘hunter-killer’ satellites that destroy their target through explosion or ballistic impact. A Soviet “Satellite destroyer” with explosive on board would approach the target and explode, destroying any spacecraft by its debris in the radius of one kilometer (tested in 1968) [14].

·      Carrier rockets with nuclear warheads, aimed at destruction of space objects (nuclear explosions in space were performed by the USA and the USSR in 1958-1962).

·      Exoatmospheric Kill Vehicle (EKV). Its mission is to engage high-speed ballistic missile warheads in the midcourse phase of flight and to destroy them using only the force of impact, or hit-to-kill. An EKV is boosted to an intercept trajectory by a boost vehicle (missile), where it separates from the boost vehicle and autonomously collides with an incoming warhead. EKV devices appear in both ground and ship based missile defense systems.

·      Shrapnel - ejection of balls and other small parts to destroy satellites, stations, carrier rockets).

·      Orbital stations. The first Soviet Orbital Piloted Station (OPS) blasted off into orbit on April 3, 1973. OPS was equipped with high speed aviation 23 mm cannon. Since the Soviet authorities did not want to disclose the existence of the top-secret “Almaz” project, the OPS-1 was announced as Salyut-2 upon reaching the orbit. Unlike its civilian counterpart - Salyut-1 - Salyut-2 transmitted signals at 19.944 MHz, the frequency common for Soviet reconnaissance satellites [27].

In future, the following types of space weapons may appear (some of them are currently under development and testing):

·      space bombers – aircraft that will bomb enemy’s objects by kinetic bombs;

·      war satellites-“bodyguards” (escorting and protection of the most important space objects);

·      space ground-based interceptors (anti-satellite defense tasks, destruction of intercontinental ballistic missile warheads and aircraft);

·      war spacecraft (struggling against enemy’s satellites, destroying important ground targets);

·      gigantic space mirrors that can redirect a laser from the Earth to enemy’s war objects or illuminate territories;

·      space mines (creation of minefields in space in order to destroy enemy’s satellites);

·      space-spacemissiles.

Militarization and weaponization of space

Terms “space militarization” and “space weaponization” have been actively discussed during the recent years. These terms are used both by public figures and statesmen, and by politicians, scientists, military men, and journalists. Let us consider some of the existing opinions:

Prof. Vinogradov (retired general-lieutenant, chairman of Committee of Scientists for Global Safety and Security and Armament Control, honorary member of the Russian Academy of Military Sciences): “Space… is so far the only natural environment free of weapons, unlike land, sea, and air. … One should distinguish two approaches to military use of space. One approach is to place communication and intelligence systems, alarm systems that warn about missile attacks, navigation systems in space…, i.e. passive use of space facilities. Another approach concerns placing of different classes of weapons in space: “space-space”, “space-land”, and deploy weapons of the “land-space” class on land, in the air, and at sea… In this connection I feel doubtful about applicability of such a frequently used generalized term as “space militarization”, because military use of space is an accomplished fact. The first approach is not only acceptable, but also necessary in order to preserve national interests of countries in terms of safety. The second approach is unacceptable” [15].

Lieutenant Colonel Donald P. Christy (United States Air Force): “a space weapon as any device or system placed in earth orbit, deep space or on a celestial body (such as the moon) capable of directly engaging, defeating or destroying a target (kinetically or with energy). What this definition does not include are weapons that use space as a means to get from one point in the land/air battle space to another or originate from the land/air medium without the intent to return. Therefore, this definition excludes Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles (ICBMs), ground based ICBM interceptor missiles, ground/air launched Anti Satellite Weapons, and ground based energy weapons (such as lasers). By using the phrase “directly engaging, defeating or destroying a target,” the definition also excludes those systems that only serve as a component or enhancement to another direct delivery system or platform, for example, the role of the Global Positioning System (GPS) in a delivery of a Joint Direct Attack Monition by an aircraft” [16].

Karl P. Mueller (an associate political scientist of RAND): «Space weaponization is a subset of space militarization. If one envisions a continuum running from space systems not being used for any militarily useful purposes to satellites providing services to support terrestrial military operations (from the late 1950s for the United States) to satellites being integral parts of terrestrial weapon systems (from the 1990s) to weapons themselves being deployed in space, weaponization occurs when the upper range of the spectrum is reached. At its most extreme, space weaponization would include the deployment in quantity of a full range of space weapons, including satellite based systems for ballistic missile defense (BMD), ground- and space-based anti-satellite weapons (ASATs), and a variety of space-to-earth weapons (STEW), and these would play a central role in any type of military operations. … we have not yet crossed the principal space weaponization threshold precisely because almost everyone believes that we have not done so» [17].

John M. Logsdon (Director of the Space Policy Institute at the George Washington University’s Elliott School of International Affairs): “Space militarization describes a situation in which the military makes use of space in carrying out its missions. There is no question that space has been militarized; U.S. armed forces would have great difficulty carrying out a military mission today if denied access to its guidance, reconnaissance, and communications satellites. But to date, military systems in space are used exclusively as “force enhancers,” making air, sea, and land force projection more effective” [18].

Of course, there are other opinions. For example, after Saddam Hussein’s attempt to jam US GPS satellite signals in March 2003 General Lance Lord (commander of US Space Command) says “The war in space began during Operation Iraqi Freedom” [12]. Steven Lambakis posits that “the term weaponization may be used, in a general way, to characterize activities that countries have undertaken for nearly 60 years. In other words, the so-called weaponization of space is happening under our very noses. Space weaponization started in September 1944, when the first German V-2 missile came rocketing down from the edge of space and exploded on the residents and buildings of London” [19].

However, in general opinions coincide in the following: space militarization is a passive use of space for military purposes in order to solve secondary problems. Currently, space is not weaponized. There are no weapons deployed in space or terrestrially (in air, sea, or on the ground) meant to attack space objects, such as satellites; nor are satellite weapons deployed against terrestrial targets. At the same time, space is an increasingly vital part of military activities. Space used for communication, for surveillance and targeting over the battlefields, for weather prediction, for precise mapping and positioning of military assets, for early warning of missile and air attacks, and for general military, economic, and technological intelligence worldwide. Thus space is “militarized” and space militarization has some peacebuilding benefits, such as arms control verification. But where do we locate the line between the militarization of space and the weaponization of space, which by most accounts has not yet taken place?

Space-based defense

The notion of defense is very broad. Taking into account our previous work, further we consider only military defense. In military science, according to Wikipedia [20], “defense is the art of preventing an attack, or minimizing the damage of an attack, e.g. by preventing an enemy from conquering territory. Thus, if a party attacks an enemy who is about to attack that party, this could be called defense”. Of course, such definition leaves room for interpretation.

Now we can define the “space-based defense” as military defense using some devices in space. There are many advantages to using space-based systems, particularly as the threat matures and improves over time. Space-based systems (weapons) would always be in position. They could defend and offer protection against threats to forces arriving in theater before theater commanders have had the opportunity to establish their own theater defense capabilities. Space offers broad area coverage to protect wide array of assets from a system based in space rather than having to protect each of those assets with their own individual ground-based systems. Space-based weapons are a key hedge against a possible resurgent threat.

Before present time space-based defense developed mainly as a missile defense. Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI) is USA defense program, which originally was focused on the threat of a massive Soviet attack, but by 1991 it had switched to protection against much more limited strikes from anywhere on the globe.

Now major components of the USA space-based defense programs are SBIRS, SMTS Brilliant Eyes and the Space-Based Laser.

Space Based Infrared System, or SBIRS, is a program that is intended to combine the activities of the existing development programs into a single integrated program to most effectively meet the military’s infrared surveillance requirements. SBIRS is built to replace the current Defense Support Program and related systems. SBIRS operational requirements include four mission areas of missile warning, missile defense, technical intelligence and battle-space characterization. SBIRS is composed of eight satellites, four of which oscillate around Earth’s geo-synchronous orbit (GEO), two are on the highly elliptical orbits (HEO, or SBIRS-high), and two more are on the low Earth Orbit (LEO, or SBIRS-low).

Being a low-orbit element of SBIRS with capacity to detect and track incoming missiles, Space and Missile Tracking System, or SMTS, is a constellation of 12-24 satellites, orbiting Earth on low orbits. SMTS is designed to detect and track incoming missiles, sending trajectory data to the space-based lasers or other missile defense elements, which can provide quick response and target incoming missiles. The importance of this system is that utilizing its capacity, the alarm response can be quick enough to be able to intercept a missile in the boost stage of its trajectory. That is, the missile can be intercepted over the adversary territory within seconds of its launch.

Space-based lasers are another component necessary for the precise boost-phase interception. Unlike SBIRS or SMTS, space-based lasers are directed energy offence weapons main target of which is the boost-phase missile interception. Development of the boost-phase interception capability is very desirable because of its immediate payoff in case of a hostile ballistic missile launch. Interception in the boost-stage does not only prevent the missile from reaching its target, but also makes the launcher suffer damages inflicted by their own missile as well as the missile interceptor.

Space security

The Space Security Index is the annual, comprehensive, and integrated assessment of space security. It defines the term “space security” as “the secure and sustainable access to and use of space, and freedom from space-based threats” [21]. International developments in space security may be divided to  eight indicator areas: the Space Environment; Space Security Laws, Policies and Doctrines; Civil space programs and global utilities; Commercial Space; Space Support for Terrestrial Military Operations; Space Systems Protection; Space Systems Negation; Space-based Strike Weapons. The main trends and developments in indicator areas were posed in “Space Security 2006” [21].

Space in literature

Literature, dedicated to space, is immense. There are hundreds of books about space – scientific, science fiction, educational ones. Their review would take several volumes. That is why we will limit ourselves by literature pertaining to the Moon, because the Moon is the closest and the most approachable to a terrestrial observer special object. It was the Moon to whom many famous ancient writers addressed.

One of the first stories of the science fiction genre is probably the one written by Plutarch (46-120 A.D.) “On the Apparent Face in the Orb of the Moon”. With a reference to ancient wizards, he mentions “smooth hills” of the Moon. Surprisingly, typical smoothed shape of moon mountains, covered with a thick layer of rock debris and dust, became known only after space flights to the Moon. Besides, Plutarch wrote about smaller gravitation of the Moon and even about its mass.

Lucian of Samosata is an Assyrian-Roman rhetorician and satirist (120- after 180 A.D.) could really be called the Father of science fiction. In his book “Icaromenip” (Lat. “Icaromenippus” (about 161 A.D.), the main character flies to the Moon with the help of wings. In his book “A True Story” (Lat. “Vera Historia”, about 170 A.D.), travelers-seafarers are also blown to the Moon with a whirlwind and encounter a great number of exotic forms of extraterrestrial life, intrude into local “politics” and even take part in “star wars” for the planet of Venus.

In 1516, an epic “Furious Orland” by an Italian poet Ludovico Ariostro was published. His character flies to the Moon in a quadriga. The famous astronomer Kepler, who discovered the laws of motion of planets of the Solar system, also turned his inquisitive mind to science fiction and in 1609 wrote a novel “Dream” (published in 1634). Despite the fact that Kepler’s character appears at the Moon with the help of demonic forces, this novel turned out to be prophetical in some sense, because the author had foreseen such circumstances as dangers pertaining to interplanetary flights, impossibility of existence of life on the Moon, possibility to move using the Moon’s gravitation.

In 1638 two English bishops published two science fiction novels that are worth mentioning, as they were widely known and were republished during many years. These novels are Francisco Godwin’s “A Man on the Moon, or Tractate about a Voyage There” and John Wilkins’s “Discovery of a New World”. Godwin was probably the first one to describe the state of weightlessness. He used a flock of swans as a mover, who flew at the speed of 280 km/h and reached the Moon in 12 days. By the way, this story laid the foundation of a tradition of space utopia: his main character finds an ideal social order. Wilkins considers for the first time problems of life support and possible technical means for the flight. He thought that it is possible to create “a flying carriage” and believed that since carriages had already been created, then a flight to the Moon would be possible in the nearest future.

It was proposed to use different technical means known at that time as a means of traveling, and all these “space carriages” competed with each other in their astonishing naivety. In 1657, a science fiction novel “Space History of States and Empires of the Sun” by Cyrano de Bergerac was published. It proposes different technical means of transportation: a solar battery-aerostat, a combination of magnets, powder-charged rockets with consecutive combustion.  It was the first proposal in literature to use a rocket as a technical means of traveling to the Moon.

E.F. Burney’s “Voyage to the Moon” (1815) apparently proposes the first “space canon” – four large guns operating in parallel. A spaceship has a conical shape and looks like a partially folded umbrella, which opens at the Moon and ensures safe landing on its surface. For the first time in literature, the novel offers the first description of a “space garment”, known today as a space suit. 1864 witnessed the appearance of the first paper on the history of space flights in literature, “Worlds Imagined and Real” by a French astronomer Flammarion. Starting from the end of the 18th and beginning of the 19th centuries, alongside with the development of astronomy and other sciences, more and more realistic features appear in the enormous flow of science fiction literature. For example, in Edgar Poe’s novel “The Unparalleled Adventures of One Hans Pfall”, the description of the Earth from space is very similar to that that we know today by photographs and television, although Edgar Poe wrote it on the assumption that the air, though highly rarefied, is present all through the way from the Earth to the Moon.  Space travels in science fiction literature acquire a more realistic character.  People travel to the Moon in hermetically sealed cylinders or spheres, although these devices were launched to the Moon by canons or by other similarly incredible methods, for example, using antigravitation as a driving force. The latter method was used by Herbert Wells in his novel “The First Men in the Moon”. Even more realistic features can be found in the novels by Jules Verne: one can see some features of the “Apollo” project, for example, the return of the foreship with landing on the water in the ocean. In his famous dilogy, “From the Earth to the Moon” (1865) and “Around the Moon” (1969), Joules Verne describes a voyage to the Moon unauthorized access detail.

Let us also recollect traveling of the famous baron Munchausen in the novel by a German writer Rudolf Erich Raspe, (Rudolf Erich Raspe, “The Adventures of Baron Munchausen”, 1785), space flights of Cyrano de Bergerac in the epic of a French poet Edmond Rostand (Edmond Rostand, “Cyrano de Bergerac”, 1898).

Such well-known Russian writers as V.K. Kukhelbeker and V.F. Odoyevsy also address to the topic of space flights. In his novel “The Year 4338” (1840), Odoyevsy states, that Moon colonization is necessary in connection with the threat of overpopulation. The greatest contribution to popularization of the main problems and tasks of space exploration was made by K. E. Tsiolkovsky. His science fiction novels “On the Moon”, “Dreams of the Earth and Sky”, and “Beyond the Earth” tackle nearly all problems and tasks that had to be solved in order to perform a space flight. Amonf a great number of literature on this subject, he was probably the only writer who put real scientific ideas and calculations beyond the fiction narrative.

Tsiolkovsky’s novel “On the Moon” was first published in 1893. The aim of the novel is to tell the readers about achievements in astronomy and technology of that time in a popular, comprehensive and captivating manner. Two friends come to the Moon, travel there, observe the Earth and stars. Tsiolkovsky’s characters encountered the world of the Moon face-to-face. And it required to have a tremendous imagination to give such an astonishingly precise, colorful and emotional description of impressions of a man on the Moon − and to do so at the end of the 19th century. Of course, a modern reader will have different questions − why there are no space suits, why the characters run on the Moon surface wearing ordinary boots at the temperature of -150ºC? How did they manage to see Jupiter’s satellites with an unaided eye? First of all, one should keep in mind that “On the Moon” is a science fiction novel. Secondly, Tsiolkovsky wanted to show how a human being and earth objects would behave in physical conditions of the Moon. What would happen to a man, whose weight had been reduced in six times? How would he move, what weights w would ill he be able to lift? What would happen to a boiling samovar, to fruits taken from the Earth, in conditions of the Moon world? How one should cook food? All his narrative is like one continuous physical experiment, described in a bright and absorbing manner. This is what Tsiolkovsky’s science fiction concerns about − he omitted many important for a real space travel details, because that was not what was important to him. But at the same time his characters had seen and felt all that the American astronauts saw and felt about 80 years later. Tsiolkovsky dreamt that one day such travels would come true. Already at the end of the 19th century, he started to prepare people to space flights, he taught them not to be afraid of space, and he taught them to think not about dangers of such travels, but about natural curiosity, that stimulates a man to make new discoveries, about high interest to see something new, to experience something unknown and unwitnessed, that has always attracted human mind and feelings.

In the 20-s, a “rocket era” in science fiction started, and from pages of novels and stories various types of rockets – unmanned, manned, multi-stage, nuclear, photon, ion ones − rushed to the Moon and other celestial bodies ... An in 1959, the Soviet station “Luna-2” became the first earth object that reached the surface of the Moon, and then Neil Armstrong stepped on the Moon. And the topic of the first flight to the Moon practically disappeared from science fiction literature.

Why space is of interest to or fascinating to people?

From ancient time people turned their glances to the sky and stars. They tried to understand and explain the world around them and natural phenomena. People want to know if there is life on other planets, if there are places in the Universe, where people could live better, than on the Earth. We are a race of explorers. We are always on a quest to discover. Space is the final frontier and it is infinite. It is our future because it's in our nature. For society not to be funding deep space exploration is to deny a large part of what makes us human.

In the course of our explorations we hope find evidence of other civilizations if not living members of those societies. The confirmed existence of extraterrestrial life developed independently of our own planet's history will help to provide some additional perspective on fundamental questions like "why are we here?" If we discover that life is ubiquitous, our human-centric perspective will give way to a greater cosmic truth. If on the other hand we are able to confirm, after much exploration that we are indeed alone, that will perhaps have the greater impact.

However, not only curiosity and scientific interest attract people in space. Concern about the future also makes us look beyond the Earth. Natural resources are being exhausted, the air is getting too dirty to breathe with, the ozone layer is being destroyed, and there are overpopulation problems. It is possible that there are planets that are suitable for people of the Earth to live on. Space is an endless source of different natural resources. The resources, in terms of mineral deposits, tied up in asteroids, the Moon, Mars and other bodies could provide off-world mining sites that would allow us to stop or reduce terrestrial resource mining. The natural resources in space include metallic nickel-iron alloy, silicate minerals, hydrated minerals, bituminous material, and various volatiles, including water, ammonia, carbon dioxide, methane, and others. These have all been identified either in meteorites, or spectroscopically in asteroids and comets. People need energy, and energy is in abundance in space, the Sun can serve as a practically inexhaustible source of energy. If the major part of industrial plants is carried out into space, it will remove all restrictions and limitations pertaining to lack of raw materials or energy, to destruction of the Earth’s ecology, and it will finally make possible to satisfy material needs of people in the scale of the whole planet. Laboratories in space could perform experiments you wouldn't want to do on Earth because of the risks involved to the population. Potential deadly experiments with viruses and bacteria that hold the possibility of mass casualty in the event of an accident could more safely be performed from either space stations or planetary scientific outposts, greatly reducing the risk of catastrophe.

We are also worried about threat from space. The Earth has already experienced asteroid attacks. There is no guarantee that another collision of the Earth with a space object, the planet will survive. The earth's existence is finite. It may very well be billions of years before the Sun burns out or explodes, but it may only be months or years before some extremist regime or fundamentalist group set in motion a chain of events that cause the annihilation of the human race. We must expand beyond one environment to decrease the likelihood that a single catastrophe will cause our extinction.

Objective 2 – Background: History of Man in Space

Evolution of cosmic ideas

Having asked himself the questions – who I am, where we came from – a man has simultaneously posed another question – what space is. The first systematic notions about space reached us in the form of myths. We still use the names of planets and constellations that they obtained based on natural myths in Ancient Greece. The first understanding of the world that can be called scientific was formulated in the antiquity period. “Space”, or “cosmos” in Greek, means order, arrangement, harmony (anything organized). Philosophers of the Ancient Greece interpreted “cosmos” as the Universe, considering it an ordered harmonic system. They opposed “cosmos” to disorder, chaos. For example, Heraklith of Ephesus considered, that space, or “cosmos”, is an absolute order and harmony, a closed sphere, at the center of which the Earth is situated. He introduces the notion of the world year (10800 years), during which “cosmos” appears, develops and burns down in flame, being substituted by Chaos. Pythagoras - the author of the term “space” in its modern understanding − proposed a pyrocentric system of the world, according to which the Sun and planets under the music of celestial spheres revolve around a central flame. Pythagoras (or maybe his student Parmenides) was the first to state that the Earth is a sphere. The first ones to speak about revolution of the Earth around its axis were apparently Pythagoreans Hyket and Ekfant of Syracuse. However, Pythagoreans also had ideas that even the Earth had an orbit and was not the center of the World. Phylolay (470-388 B.C.) was the first to proclaim ideas of the Pythagorean studies in his book “On the Nature”. From this book we learn about the Earth’s movement (before that the Earth has always been considered a motionless and flat center of the Universe). In Phylolay’s book the Earth is “removed” from its central position and moves along its orbit. Phylolay’s Moon looks like Earth and is inhabited (in the 5th century B.C. – that is when ideas about life on other planets appeared!) by the same animals and plants, but bigger in size and more beautiful ones.

The peak of the ancient scientific achievements is Aristotle’s doctrine. Aristotle’s followers completed creation of an ordered scholastic system of knowledge that reflected invariability and perfection of space. According to scholastic view, the Universe is eternal, but is periodically destroyed so as to be revived again in the next cosmic cycle. Aristotle stated that only the changeable sublunary world was subject to destruction, but regions above the Moon were eternal. Stars consisted of a divine substance and hence had power over everything that happened in the sublunary world.

Duration of the “Great year”, according to Plato, is 760,000 years, and according to Ptolemy is 36,000 years. After works by Plato and Aristotle, no serious philosophers challenged the theory about the Earth’s spherical shape.

After the end of the slave-owning epoch, the cosmic philosophy of the ancient world could not but reach a deadlock. And that is exactly what happened. At the end of the ancient period the philosophic school of Neo-Platonists came to a conclusion, that space was a desert, because  there was no personality. Plotin, the founder of Neo-Platonism (3rd century A.D.) taught that space was an undefined, devoid of any personal qualities, acceptor of eternal ideas (eidoses), the source of which was the Universal Whole.  The Universal Whole produced reason (nous) that contained all ideas, and the world soul that contained all individual souls. It took only one step to exaltation of a personality, and this step was made by philosophy of monotheism (Christianity, Islam). The basis of this doctrine was not the nature any more, but a demiurge – an absolute personality who was “higher” and “earlier” than space. However, having started in the antique times, this philosophy flourished only in the Middle Ages. The scholastic system of the world that absorbed elements of mythological notions appeared very stable and formed a basis of the European science for over 1,500 years, up until the scientific revolution marked by studies of Copernicus, Galileo and Newton. However, this does not mean that the picture of the world accepted in the Middle Ages did not experience any changes and did not have its peculiarities.

The middle ages started from the breakdown of the great Roman Empire. General decadence resulted in the appearance of strange pictures of the world. For example, Kosma Indikplov, basing on a story about divine tabernacle, believed that the Universe had a shape of a box. Hervasius of Tilberia considered that the Earth was square, and so on. But still the cosmogony of the Middle Ages was determined by two sources – the Bible and Aristotle’s doctrine. The world was considered to be a huge symbolic system, a sort of collection of ideas. Every external phenomenon was considered to be an act of God.

The Renaissance covers a period from the 14th to the beginning of the 18th centuries. One of the most prominent achievements of natural studies of that time was the establishment of a heliocentric system of the world by Nicholas Copernicus (1473-1543). The main ideas comprising the core of this system are the following: the Earth is not a stationary center of the world, but it revolves around its axis and simultaneously around the Sun that is the center of the world. This discovery made a scientific revolution, as it disproved the picture of the world based on the geocentric system of Aristotle-Ptolemy that had existed more than a thousand years.

The central idea of cosmologic doctrine of Giordano Bruno (1548-1600) is a statement about infinity of the Universe. “It [the Universe] is not capable of comprehension and therefore is endless and limitless, and to that extent infinite and indeterminable…”. The statement about infinity of the Universe allowed Bruno to pose a new question about the center of the world, denying not only the geocentric, but also the heliocentric system. Neither the Sun nor the Earth can be the center of the Universe, because there are infinitely many worlds. And each world has its center – its star.

Kepler calculated paths of planets motion. They turned out to be ellipses having the Sun in one of the focuses (the First Kepler’s Law). Kepler also discovered the Second Law that determined the speed of planet’s motion at each point of its orbit, and the Third Law that established the dependence of the distance between the planet and the Sun on the period of its revolution around the Sun.

With the help of a telescope, Galileo saw mountains on the Moon, spots on the Sun, and discovered four Jupiter’s satellites that ran around the planet at different distances. That was a serious argument supporting the idea that in the Solar system all planets move around the biggest body – the Sun, but not around the Earth.

The founder of the modern physics, Newton, produced a simple and strange picture of the world – an absolutely empty space that had no boundaries and that was subject to the Euclidian geometry, where from the times of creations stars and planets revolved according to the law of gravity. Newton assumed that in general stars were evenly distributed in the Universe. However, one may demonstrate that if in such a Universe a universal law of gravitation exists, then such a Universe is unstable and with time it should either concentrate into a point, or into an innumerable number of spheres. Since this is not observed, then there should be some external “Agent” (Newton’s term) that makes the system stable. Such an “agent” can be God’s will. Despite some weak points and contradictions, the mathematical theory of the Universe established by Newton allowed him to find brilliant solutions of a number of practical tasks: establish a theory of the Moon’s movement, calculate motion of planets and comets, explain tides and ebbs, etc.  However, Newton’s world was static, devoid of development and preserved properties obtained from God at the first day of creation. This weak point was corrected later by Kant and by Dallas, both of whom have independently proposed a hypothesis that the Solar system had originated from a nebula.

Speaking about the main peculiarities of the picture of the world at the period of classic natural sciences, one should but mention A. Humboldt, who was rightfully called Aristotle of the 19th century. In his main paper “Space” he gave a systematic physical description of the Universe – an encyclopedic abridgement of knowledge about space at the middle of the century. The scientific paradigm that established in natural sciences after Newton’s works predominated till the beginning of the 20th century, developing consecutively in new spheres of knowledge.

In the 20th centuries, scientific ideas about space have considerably changed and filled with new content. First of all, one should mention a concept of K.E. Tsiolkovsky about humankind as an active creative force that develops and transforms space. A concept of the Universe as a unified self-organizing evolving system was also formulated, and problems of cosmology and physics of the microworld became closer. In the 20th century, industrial space exploration started as a new medium of industrial activity of the humankind, and a new definition of the term “space” that we presented earlier was formulated.

The history of people’s exploration of space

For centuries humans dreamed of conquering time and space and for centuries so it remained -just a dream. Finally, the 20th century arrived and with it the phenomenal ascent of science and technology that allowed humanity to progress faster and farther than during all previous recorded history. Let’s look at the some significant events in the history of exploration of outer space [22]:

·      1957, Oct. 4: World’s first artificial satellite Sputnik-1 is launched.

·      1958, March 17: The Vanguard (TV-4), the first satellite to use solar energy, reaches orbit.

·      1959, Jan. 1-2: Luna-1, the first spacecraft to escape Earth orbit, is launched.

·      1959, Sept. 12: Luna-2 the first man-made object to impact the Moon.

·      1959, Oct. 3: Luna-3 photographs far side of the Moon.

·      1960, April 1: The US launches Tiros-1, the first weather-monitoring satellite.

·      1960, April 13: The US successfully launches Transit 1B, the first navigational satellite.

·      1960, Aug. 19: Two dogs, Belka and Strelka, landed onboard the prototype of the Vostok spacecraft (Korabl Sputnik-5), becoming first animals returning from orbit.

·      1961, Feb. 12: Venera-1 probe launched toward Venus.

·      1961, April 12: Yuri Gagarin completes world’s first manned spaceflight onboard Vostok spacecraft.

·      1962, Aug. 11-15: Two manned spacecrafts, Vostok 3 and 4, orbit the Earth simultaneously.

·      1962, Dec. 14: Mariner-2 completes the first Venus flyby.

·      1963, June 16-19: Valentina Tereshkova, the world’s first woman in space completed orbital flight onboard Vostok-6 spacecraft.

·      1963, July 26: The Syncom-2 communications satellite reaches synchronous orbit.

·      1964, Aug. 19: The Syncom-3 communications satellite becomes the world’s first geostationary satellite.

·      1964, Oct. 12-13: A first three-member crew orbited Earth onboard Voskhod spacecraft.

·      1965, March 18: Alexei Leonov conducts world’s first spacewalk during the 24-hour, 16-orbit Voskhod-2 mission.

·      1965, July 15: Mariner-4 completes flyby of Mars.

·      1965, Nov. 26: The Diamant rocket orbited the first French satellite, the A-1, making the country the third space power.

·      1966, Feb. 3: Luna-9 conducts soft-landing and scientific research on the surface of the Moon.

·      1966, March 16: US spacecraft Gemini-8 completes world’s first manual docking with Agena-8.

·      1967, June 12: Venera-4, the first probe to enter the atmosphere of Venus, blasts off from Baikonur.

·      1968, Dec. 24: The US spacecraft Apollo-8 with the crew of three completes world’s first translunar flight and orbiting of the Moon.

·      1969, July 20: The Apollo-11 astronauts land and walk on the surface of the Moon.

·      1970, April 24: China launches an artificial satellite onboard domestically built rocket.

·      1970, July 22: The Venera-7 lander transmits data from the surface of Venus.

·      1971, April 19: The Salyut-1, the first orbital station is launched. Its crew of three dies on landing.

·      1971, Oct. 28: Great Britain launches the Prospero satellite onboard the Black Arrow rocket from the launch site in Australia.

·      1971, Dec. 2: The Mars-3 lander reaches the surface of Mars. Only few seconds of data had been received on Earth, before the spacecraft fails.

·      1973, May 14: The US Saturn-5 rocket launches Skylab orbital lab. Three crews visit and work onboard the station.

·      1973, Dec. 4: The Pioneer-10 completes flyby of Jupiter.

·      1974, March 29: The Mariner-10 completes flyby of Mercury.

·      1975, July 17: The Soviet Soyuz and US Apollo spacecraft dock in space.

·      1975, Oct. 22: Venera-9 transmitted first ever images from the surface of Venus.

·      1978, Jan. 20: The Progress-1 the first cargo ship to resupply the space station is launched.

·      1979, Sept. 1: Pioneer-11 completes flyby of Saturn.

·      1980, July 18: India launches Rokhini satellite onboard its own SLV-3 rocket from its own launch site.

·      1981, April 12: The US Shuttle Columbia blasts off into the first test flight.

·      1981, Nov. 12: The US Shuttle Columbia returns to orbit, becoming the first reusable spacecraft.

·      1983, November: The European Spacelab conducts its first orbital mission onboard US Shuttle.

·      1986, Jan. 24: The Voyager-2 becomes the first and only spacecraft in the 20th century to flyby and study Uranus.

·      1986, February 20: The core module of the Mir space station is launched. Its first expedition shuttles between Mir and Salyut-7.

·      1988, Sept. 19: Israel’s Shavit rocket successfully launched Ofeq-1 (Oz-1) - country’s first satellite.

·      1988, Nov. 15: The Energia booster launches unmanned Buran reusable shuttle, which lands automatically after two orbits.

·      1989, August: The Voyager-2 becomes the first spacecraft to flyby and study Neptune.

·      1990, April 24-29: The Shuttle Discovery deploys Hubble Space Telescope (STS-31).

·      1991, May: The first commercial passenger, British citizen Helen Sharman, visits Mir.

·      1995, June 27-July 7: The US Space Shuttle (STS-71) docks to the Mir space station for the first time.

·      1995, Dec. 7: The Galileo spacecraft enters orbit around Jupiter.

·      1997, Mars Pathfinder lands on Mars and deploys the first rover on the Red Planet.

·      1998, August: North Korea launched Daepodong-1 rocket, officially announced as a satellite launch, which apparently did not reach orbit.

·      1998, Nov. 20: The Zarya/FGB control module, the first element of the International Space Station blasts off from Baikonur.

·      2001, Feb. 12: At the end of its mission, the NASA’s NEAR spacecraft touched down on the surface of the asteroid Eros, which the spacecraft was orbiting since previous year.

·      2001, April 28: Dennis Tito, the first space tourist, blasts off toward the ISS onboard Soyuz TM-32 spacecraft.

·      2003, Oct. 15: China becomes the third nation to conduct manned space flight, launching the Shenzhou-5 spacecraft, with a 38-year-old Lt. Colonel Yang Liwei onboard.

·      2004, Jan. 2: The Stardust spacecraft flies by comet Wild 2, collecting samples.

·      2004, July 1: The Cassini spacecraft entered orbit around Saturn.

·      2005, Jan. 14: The Huygens probe from the Cassini spacecraft successfully lands on the surface of Saturn’s moon Titan and transmits imagery during the descent and from the surface.

·      2005, July 4: NASA’s Deep Impact 1 probe to approach Comet Tempel 1 and release the probe, which will impact the comet’s core some 24 hours later.

·      2006: “Voyager 1”, already the most distant human-made object in the cosmos, reaches 100 astronomical units from the Sun. That means the spacecraft, which launched in 1977, will be 100 times more distant from the Sun than Earth is.

Space technologies on Earth

The applications for space technologies on Earth are myriad and include telecommunications, navigation, medicine and health care, water management, leisure and lifestyle, agriculture, mining, oil and gas exploration, automobile industry, textile industry, buildings and houses and many more. Just a glance at some of the success stories will indicate the breadth of areas and products which have been enhanced by the transfer of space technologies.

Since 1976, over 1500 NASA technologies have benefited industry, improved the quality of life, and created jobs [23-24]. Here are some of the contributions of the US Apollo program:

·      Cool suits, which kept Apollo astronauts comfortable during moon walks, are today worn by race car drivers, nuclear reactor technicians, shipyard workers, people with multiple sclerosis and kids with a congenital disorder known as hypohidrotic ectodermal displasia.

·      Special kidney dialysis machines were developed as a result of a NASA developed chemical process that could remove toxic waste from used dialysis fluid.

·      A cardiovascular conditioner developed for astronauts in space led to the development of a physical therapy and athletic development machine used by football teams, sports clinics and medical rehabilitation centers.

·      Cordless power tools and appliances are one of the most successful commercial spinoffs of space-based technology.

·      Athletic shoe design and manufacture also benefited from Apollo. Space suit technology is incorporated into a shoe’s external shell. A stress-free “blow molding” process adapted from NASA space suit design is also used in the shoe’s manufacture.

·      Insulation barriers made of aluminum foil laid over a core of propylene or mylar, which protected astronauts and their spacecraft’s delicate instruments from radiation, is used to protect cars and trucks and dampen engine and exhaust noise.

·      Vacuum metallizing techniques led to an extensive line of commercial products, from insulated outer garments to packaging for foods, from wall coverings to window shades, from life rafts to candy wrappings and from reflective blankets to photographic reflectors.

·      Water purification technology used on the Apollo spacecraft is now employed in several spinoff applications to kill bacteria, viruses and algae in community water supply systems and cooling towers. Filters mounted on faucets can reduce lead in water supplies.

·      Freeze-dried food solved the problem of what to feed an astronaut on the long-duration Apollo missions.

·      A hospital food service system employs a cook/chill concept for serving food. The system allows staff to prepare food well in advance, maintain heat, visual appeal and nutritional value while reducing operating costs.

·      A hollow retroreflector, a mirror-like instrument that reflects light and other radiation back to the source, is used as a sensor to detect the presence of hazardous gases in oil fields, refineries, offshore platforms, chemical plants, waste storage sites and other locations where gases could be released into the environment.

·      A process for bonding dry lubricant to space metals led to the development of surface enhancement coatings, or synergistic coatings, which are used in applications from pizza making to laser manufacture. Each coating is designed to protect a specific metal group or group of metals to solve problems encountered under operating conditions, such as resistance to corrosion and wear.

The US Space Shuttle Program has generated more than 100 technology spinoffs. Some of the shuttle’s contributions are:

·      Artificial Heart - The technology used in space shuttle fuel pumps led to the development of a miniaturized ventricular assist pump by NASA and renowned heart surgeon Dr. Michael DeBakey.

·      Balance Evaluation Systems - Devices built to measure the equilibrium of space shuttle astronauts when they return from space are widely used by major medical centers to diagnose and treat patients suffering head injury, stroke, chronic dizziness and central nervous system disorders.

·      Diagnostic Instrument - NASA technology was used to create a compact laboratory instrument for hospitals and doctor offices that more quickly analyzes blood, accomplishing in 30 seconds what once took 20 minutes.

·      Gas Detector - A gas leak detection system, originally developed to monitor the shuttle’s hydrogen propulsion system, is being used by the Ford Motor Company in the production of a natural gas-powered car.

·      Infrared Thermometer - Infrared sensors developed to remotely measure the temperature of distant stars and planets, led to the development of the hand-held optical sensor thermometer. Placed inside the ear canal, the thermometer provides an accurate reading in two seconds or less.

·      Vehicle Tracking System - Tracking information originally used onboard Space Shuttle missions now helps track vehicles on Earth. This commercial spinoff allows vehicles to transmit a signal back to a home base. Municipalities today use the software to track and reassign emergency and public works vehicles. It also is used by vehicle fleet operations, such as taxis, armored cars and vehicles carrying hazardous cargo.

ESA and its industrial contractors actively promote technology transfer from space to the ground. ESA’s Technology Transfer and Promotion Office [25] has successfully transferred over 200 space technologies to non-space sectors, such as:

·      electrically cooled underwear developed from the space suits of astronauts;

·      to reduce vibration in newly designed cars, a German firm markets software first used for ESA’s Columbus Laboratory on the International Space Station;

·      a biomedical camera company in the UK has a new way to spot cancer cells using a superconducting detector developed by ESA’s space scientists;

·      a ground penetrating radar to detect cracks in mine tunnels;

·      several of the technologies used in the design and manufacture of modern cars and trucks come from materials and systems that were developed for applications in space and are being used to improve not only their cost and performance but also their comfort and safety – airbags, carbon brakes, navigation systems, vibration damping, insulation, cooling systems and many more;

·      cleaner fuels and solar energy used to power satellites are already starting to power cars and buses;

·      the hand-held device which incorporates satellite navigation technologies into the personal navigator to help blind people find their way around city streets.

Objects that have been put into space in my lifetime

I was burn in 1992. Since this year many different objects were launched into space. The Online Index of Objects Launched into Outer Space [9] provides a quick means to access information provided to the United Nations in accordance with the Convention on Registration of Objects Launched into Outer Space and General Assembly resolution 1721B. Currently the Index contains information on objects launched from 1957 to the present. According to this Index, since 1992 more than 1600 registered objects were launched into outer space. The table below presents number of objects launched from 1992 to 2006 year. Some of these objects were listed in section “The history of people’s exploration of space”.

Year

# of objects

example

1992

130

21/01/1992, COSMOS 2175 (Russia) - Investigation of the upper atmosphere and outer space

1993

108

13/01/1993, MOLNIYA 1 (Russia) - Operation of the long-range telephone and telegraph radio-communications system, transmission of television programmes to stations in the Orbita network

1994

123

08/01/1994, SOYUZ TM-18 (Russia) - Transport to the Mir orbital station of the crew for the 15th main mission composed of the cosmonauts V. M. Afanasev, Y. V. Usachev and V. V. Polyakov

1995

104

19/04/1995, GFZ 1 (Russia for Germany) - The GFZ-1 satellite is intended for investigation of the Earth's gravitational field

1996

100

11/01/1996, STS 72 (ENDEAVOUR F-10) (USA) - reusable space transportation system

1997

151

21/01/1997, STS 81 (ATLANTIS F-18) (USA) - reusable space transportation system

1998

158

07/01/1998, LUNAR PROSPECTOR (USA) - Spacecraft engaged in practical applications and uses of space technology such as weather or communications. Celestis space burial capsule containing ashes of Eugene Shoemaker included in object.

1999

129

03/01/1999, MARS POLAR LANDER (USA) - Spacecraft engaged in practical applications and uses of space technology such as weather or communications

2000

121

03/02/2000, COSMOS 2369 (Russia) - The space object is intended for assignments on behalf of the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation

2001

87

19/04/2001, CANADARM 2           (Canada) - Assembly and maintenance of the International Space Station

2002

96

04/02/2002, Mission Demonstration Test Satellite (Japan) - The objectives of Mission Demonstration Test Satellite 1 (MDS-1) are to verify the function of commercial parts in orbit, to verify minimization technology for components and to measure space environment data (radiation, and so forth).

2003

88

12/04/2003, ASIASAT 4 (China) - Fixed-satellite telecommunications and broadcasting services with an expected operational lifespan of 15 years.

2004

72

13/03/2004, ROSETTA (European Space Agency) - a deep-space exploratory satellite that will explore the comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. Rosetta is the first probe ever designed to enter orbit around a comet’s nucleus and release a lander onto its surface.

2005

71

20/01/2005, UNIVERSITETSKYA (TATYANA) (Russia) - The small space object is intended for science education purposes. The launch was scheduled to coincide with the two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the founding of Lomonosov Moscow State University.

2006

89

11/03/2006, HOTBIRD 7A (France) - telecommunications satellite

Space objects that had been predicted in the past

Predictions in literature are a vast and complicated topic for discussion. Some people consider that such predictions do not exist, and correspondence between predicted and real things is largely factitious. But let’s leave these debates beyond the scope of our report and still make a try to find some processes and objects that have been described in science fiction literature and that resemble the really existing ones [26]:

·      Jules Verne did predict lunar spacecraft and weightlessness (1865); he correctly predicts the size of the first Moon crew as three men (same as Apollo) and accurately sizes the Columbiad as about the size of the Apollo command module which first orbited the Moon with men in 1968. Another Verne foresight was the use of retro-rocketry with his attachment of a type of retro-rocket to “break the fall” of his craft on reaching the Moon.

·      Frank Paul in 1928 painted in magazine “Amazing Stories” planetary lander “Model T”.

·      Thea Von Harbou (“The Girl in the Moon”, 1929) - rocket fins for aerodynamic stability; the consultants for the movie were German rocket scientists. Their sizing of the Earth launch rocket is remarkably close to that of a Saturn V moon rocket. The German scientists included a VAB (Vertical Assembly Building).

·      Clustered rocket boosters were predicted in 1929.

·      The “Wonder Quarterly” illustrator, Frank R. Paul, predicted in 1929 an extravehicular activity (EVA) with pressure suited astronauts, life support tethers, and guidance gun (later created by NASA using compressed gas rather than combustible propellant).

·      Construction of orbital space station complete with living quarters using material ferried up and regular service visits was predicted in 1945.

·      Arthur Clarke in his “Radioworld” predicted, that an artificial satellite, launched at a circular equatorial orbit at the height 35,803 km above the earth surface would have a 24-hour period of revolution around the Earth, i. e. it will stay fixed with respect to any point at the earth surface. All satellites used for retransmission of a TV signal are geostationary. In honor of the writer, this orbit was called “the Clarke Belt”.

·      Solar- and light-sails were predicted in 1920.

·      Hugo Gernsbak (Ralph 124C 41+) and Robert Heinlein “The Roads Must Roll” both described a solar battery. Robert Heinlein in his “Coventry” described spacecrafts using the energy of solar batteries.

·      Streamlined crew modules for atmospheric entry were predicted in 1954.

·      Spaceships with ion engines are one of the most popular means of transport in science fiction novels. Ion engines were installed at the NASA research station Deep Space 1, at the ESA’s telecommunication satellite Artemis, and at the ESA’s interplanetary station SMART 1.

·      Alfred Bester predicted space tourism in The Stars My Destination (1956).

·      Unmanned flying machines can be found in Joules Verne’s “Unusual Adventures of Barsack’s Expedition”.

·      Murray Leinster in his “First Contact” described a spacesuit with an engine; a spacesuit described by Clifford Simak in the “Cosmic Engineers” also had a rocket pack.

·      In their 1982 book The Descent of Anansi, Larry Niven and Steven Barnes predicted that two satellites linked by a cable and passing through Earth's magnetic field could generate an electrical current. NASA launched an experimental tethered satellite in 1992 and reflew the mission in 1996. Today, the only tethered satellite in orbit is the Tether Physics and Survivability Experiment, launched in 2005.

Objective 3 – Space as an Area for Military Competition

Military events in space

From 1958 to 1962, the US and USSR conducted over a dozen nuclear tests in the Earth’s upper atmosphere or in space - the highest at an altitude of 540 km.

On October 10, 1984 the Soviet laser testing centre Terra-3 was used to track the space shuttle Challenger with a low power laser. This caused malfunctions to on-board equipment and temporary blinding of the crew, leading to a US diplomatic protest.

In October 1997, the US Air Force commissioned a test of an ASAT system based on the MIRACL laser - a megawatt-class chemical laser located at the White Sands Missile Range in New Mexico. This system was directed toward a satellite orbiting 420 km above the Earth. The MIRACL laser apparently had technical difficulties, but the results of the test were startling. A lower-power (30-watt) laser intended for alignment of the system and tracking of the satellite was the primary laser source used during the test, and it appeared that this lower-power laser was sufficiently powerful itself to blind the satellite temporarily, although it could not destroy the sensor.

Four dozen satellites from nearly two dozen nations supported the 1999 North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) military campaign against the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (FRY) in southeastern Europe. It was the largest armada of spacecraft ever brought to bear on a single war in history.

Dozens of satellites from the United States and its international coalition supported the American military campaign against terrorists in the Islamic State of Afghanistan in 2001.

Satellites from the United States and its international coalition partners supported the American military buildup around the Republic of Iraq in 2003.

On January 11, 2007 the anti-satellite missile lifted off from the Xichang site, lofting a “kill vehicle”, which then directly impacted and destroyed a functioning Chinese satellite. It was apparently a fourth launch of the system and its first success.

Integration of military and civilian space assets

In the past few years the military has increasingly relied on commercial and civilian space assets, owned and operated by foreign, domestic, and even international entities. Such non-military organizations may provide cheap and technologically advanced space commodities in a number of areas - launch, communications, remote sensing, weather etc. Even in situations in which the military relies on its own space assets (such as navigation, launch, and surveillance), partnerships with and investment in non-military entities are common.

The development and use of space technology for military and civil applications generally occurred in parallel, but often civil space technologies crossed into military use (and vice versa). Now we’ll review some major cooperative efforts between the civilian, commercial, and military sectors in several technologies.

Launching Facilities and Services

The launch service providers are often commercial companies such as Boeing and Lockheed Martin. These same commercial entities support commercial launches, civilian governmental launches, and military launches. Boeing and Lockheed Martin, for example, provide launch vehicles and services for commercial launches, provide services for shuttle launches through their joint venture as United Space Alliance (USA). The military, NASA, and the commercial sector have all expended great efforts and investment, often in direct partnership, in an attempt to reach the common goal of reducing the expense of delivering satellites to orbit.

Communications and Remote Sensing/Earth Observation by Satellite

Satellite communications systems have long been the backbone of the commercial space industry. Although the military has its own satellite communication systems, these systems cannot alone handle the military’s increasing demand for communications services - a demand which has risen sharply as the military moves real-time data and video from headquarters to military commanders deployed to foreign areas of operation. Furthermore, the military needs compact, mobile communications systems, which is the very technology gaining in popularity in civilian and commercial sectors.

Remote sensing is the collection of data which is processed into images of the surface features of the earth. Once confined to national security objectives benefiting the military and intelligence sectors, remote sensing is now being developed and used for civilian and commercial ends such as environmental monitoring, pollution tracking, natural disaster prediction and response, agriculture planning, and mapping. The easy access to such high-resolution data, while a national security concern, also offers great benefit to the military sector.

In the earliest years of the “Space Age”, satellites were mainly useful in maintaining peace and stability through reconnaissance, intelligence-gathering, early warning, and as the National Technical Means (NTM) of verification for monitoring arms control compliance. Recent years have seen increasing military reliance on satellites as “force multipliers” or “force enablers” improving the performance, lethality, and effectiveness of ground, air, and naval forces and weapons, both during peace and war. The interdependence of military and nonmilitary space systems is a global and intentional phenomenon, based on advances in technology, proliferation of technology, market forces, and political linkage of space technology with other issues. Here are some examples of U.S. military reliance on commercial sector space services:

·      In 1991, the U.S. military procured commercial remote sensing imagery from a non-U.S. company during Desert Storm (The French SPOT Image satellite system). Commercial satellite communications services were critical to U.S. Army missions.

·      In 1995, the U.S. Navy bought more than two million minutes of service on an intergovernmental satellite system constellation  (Inmarsat), and many Navy ships communicate through the system today.

·      The U.S. Government has leveraged commercially-developed direct broadcast satellite technology for its Global Broadcast Service.

·      During the first Gulf War Coalition forces used Arabsat satellite for military communications.

.

Military-use objects now in space that had been predicted in the past

Some military-use space objects had been predicted in the past by science fiction writers. For example:

·      The prototype of the laser has been described by Herbert Wells in "The War of the Worlds" (1898). Wells's Martians leveled London with heat rays.

·      In 1945, Arthur C. Clarke proposed in an issue of “Wireless World” the use of geostationary satellites for communications with ground stations.

Bibliography

1.     The Nine Planets. A Multimedia Tour of the Solar System by Bill Arnett. http://www.nineplanets.org.

2.     The Solar System. http://www.solarviews.com/cap/misc/solarsystem.htm.

3.     The Milky Way Galaxy. http://www.astro.umd.edu/education/astro/mw/mw.html.

4.     Introduction to the Atmosphere. http://www.ucar.edu/learn/1_1_1.htm.

5.     NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE. The Atmosphere. http://www.srh.noaa.gov/srh/jetstream/atmos/atmos_intro.htm.

6.     Atmospheric Structure. http://www.albany.edu/faculty/rgk/atm101/structur.htm.

7.     http://www.spacedebate.org.

8.     The official U.S. Registry of Space Objects Launched into Outer Space. http://www.usspaceobjectsregistry.state.gov.

9.     The United Nations Register of Space Objects Launched into Outer Space. http://www.unoosa.org/oosa/osoindex.html.

10.  Robert Preston, Dana J. Johnson, Sean J. A. Edwards, Michael D. Miller, Calvin Shipbaugh. Space Weapons Earth Wars. RAND Report. http://www.rand.org/pubs/monograph_reports/MR1209/MR1209.ch3.pdf.

11.  Katz-Hyman, Michael and Michael Krepon. “Viewpoint: Space Weapons and Proliferation”. Non Proliferation Review. Vol. 12, No. 2. July 2005.

12.  Wade L. Huntley. “The Weaponization of Space:  U.S. Strategy in Global Context”. Presentation to the ISU Space & National Security Theme Day, University of British Columbia, July 2005. http://www.ligi.ubc.ca/admin/Centres/527/WH%20-%20The%20Weaponization%20of%20Space%20July%2025%2005.pdf.

13.  Encyclopedia Astronautica. Star Wars. http://www.astronautix.com/craftfam/starwars.htm.

14.  Satellite destroyer. http://www.cosmoworld.ru/spacehistory/projects/istr.html.

15.  Vinogradov M.S. “Problems of military use of space”. A lecture for students of the course ‘Nonproliferation and Reduction of Weapons of Mass Destruction and National Security’, Moscow Institute of Technical Physics. http://www.armscontrol.ru/course/lectures03a/msv30401a.htm.

16.  Donald P. Christy. “United States Policy on Weapons in Space”. USAWC Strategy Research Project. U.S. Army War College. Mar. 2006.

17.  Karl P. Mueller. “Is the Weaponization of Space Inevitable?”. http://www.isanet.org/noarchive/mueller.html.

18.  Logsdon, John M. “Just Say Wait to Space Power”. Issues in Science and Technology. Vol. 17, No. 3. Spring 2001.

19.  “Future Security in Space: Commercial, Military, and Arms Control Trade-Offs”. http://cns.miis.edu/pubs/opapers/op10/op10.pdf.

20.  The Free Encyclopedia. http://www.wikipedia.org.

21.  The Space Security Index. http://www.spacesecurity.org.

22.  http://www.russianspaceweb.com

23.  NASA spinoff home page. http://www.sti.nasa.gov/tto.

24.  NASA Facts. Benefits from Apollo: Giant Leaps in Technology. NASA, FS-2004-07-002-JSC, July 2004.

25.  ESA’s Technology Transfer Program. http://www.esa.int/SPECIALS/Technology_Transfer/index.html.

26.  Some predictions in science fiction. http://www.outzone.ru/ideas.ph​tml.

27.  The Almaz Space Station Program. http://www.svengrahn.pp.se/histind/Almprog/almprog.htm.